Tags: bike trainer, bike trainer price, gears, indoor trainer, resistance, road realistic, What Kind Of Indoor Bike Trainer Should I Buy?
What Kind Of Indoor Bike Trainer Should I Buy?
I am wondering what the difference is (besides price) in trying to decide what kind of indoor bike trainer to purchase?
Can you please explain the difference between the different kinds of bike trainers and what kind should I look for if I want to simulate road-type riding.
Thanks
Ok, in general you have a five different trainers to look at.
* Wind Trainer
* Magnetic Trainer
* Fluid Trainer
* Rim Drive Trainer
* Roller Trainer
Lets explain each of them one by one.
Wind Trainer
Basically a wind trainer uses a fan for resistance. Your back tire sits on a roller and the fan (depending on the size of it) helps to give resistance as you pedal faster. Wind trainers are noisy and they generally provide the least amount of resistance. On the positive side, wind trainers are one of the cheapest type of bike trainers that you can buy. And the negative is that they give the least road like feel of any of the indoor trainers.
(Magnetic Trainer
Magnetic trainers are used by the gamut of cyclists, from beginner to advanced. You will find very inexpensive magnetic trainers as well as those hitting over $300. By inexpensive, just take a look at the Bell Motivator Mag indoor bike trainer below. A magnetic trainer uses a series of magnets which provide the resistance. Imagine positive magnets on one side of a flywheel and another flywheel having negative magnets. They attract each other but are a certain distance away. Now, what happens if you can change the setting on the bike trainer or through a remote handlebar adjuster where it brings these magnets closer together. Well, your resistance has just increased. Now, what if you have 3 levels of resistance? What if you have 5 levels of resistance? Magnetic trainers provide middle of the road resistance and are less noisy than wind trainers.
(Fluid Trainer
Fluid trainers are mainly used by advanced riders, however you'll find some with prices that are comparable to magnetic trainers. I'll state this flat out. Fluid trainers are the most road realistic trainer that you can buy. You will find that the USA Cycling Team uses a fluid trainer. Some will argue with me and say that a roller trainer (running on both tires) offers the best road like feel but I've found that roller trainers require 100% concentration while riding and I still don't feel that they get the resistance that you will find with a fluid trainer. With a fluid trainer, fluid is housed inside a chamber. As an impeller moves faster and faster within the fluid, the pressure/resistance builds. Fluid trainers also have (a general statement) more features than the previously mentioned bike trainers.
New 2010 Green Kurt Kinetic Road Machine with Riser Ring, Power Computer & Floor Mat Package
| Rating: |  (22 reviews) |
|---|---|
| $428.97 | |
| No | |
 | |
Rim Drive Trainer
I see rim drive trainers as mainly used by mountain bike riders. Meaning, instead of your rear tire running on a roller as in the wind trainer, magnetic trainer, and fluid trainer, a rim drive trainer uses the rim of your rear tire. The rim drive trainer connects to the rim and the bike is propelled with resistance thanks from the help of the trainer. You will not need to change your rear tire to a slick as you should with all the above trainers. So, you can use your mountain bike and just keep that back tire on. If you have a mountain bike, I would not look at any other trainer than a rim drive trainer.
(Roller Trainer
When using a roller trainer, both tires on your bike move on the rollers. Most roller trainers will require you to initially (as a beginner) setup next to a wall so that you can maintain balance. You will fall off of a roller trainer as you are learning. You will get a road like feel or maybe a feel of riding a bike on ice at times. I find that roller trainers lack resistance (one negative) and on a personal level, I cannot maintain concentration long enough to have a long ride on a roller trainer. Since all other trainers are stable, for me, I'll do better on any other bike trainer.
| Rating: | No reviews. Be the first! |
|---|---|
| $ | |
| No | |
| |
Saturday, January 8th 2011 at 2:26 AM |
Most people consider fluid then and mag trainers the best. Wind trainers tend to be very loud and don’t ofter the best resistance, fluid very quiet and mag fairly quiet too. Choose one with remote resistance control or you have to set it before you get on to ride. Remote allows you to adjust it from your handlebars. Other than that, it’s how sturdy the frame is and quality of the roller and bearings.
I think the best is fluid with remote. I now have a mag with remote and it’s fine as well.
Saturday, January 8th 2011 at 2:26 AM |
A fluid trainer pumps oil through a series of valves to generate resistance as you pedal. A resistance trainer usually uses magnets to generate resistance. A wind trainer has a fan to generate resistance.
A fluid trainer usually gives the widest range of resistance values to simulate anything from steep uphills to easy downhills. Magnetic resistance trainers, in my experience, don’t have as wide a range. Resistance of a wind trainer usually goes up as you pedal faster in the same way as wind resistance increases as you go faster when you are outside.
In my experience, a combination fluid/magnetic resistance trainer works really well to provide a wide range of resistance and smooth pedaling.
Hope this helps.
Saturday, January 8th 2011 at 2:26 AM |
It depends on what you’re looking for. Rollers (where you balance yourself and don’t attach anything to the bike) are great for road riders. They have a natural/realistic feel, allow you to change gears, and help you improve your balance as well. The wind units for them aren’t really necessary, but do provide a little more resistance and realistic feel.
The trainers (where you clamp the bike by the rear of the frame/axle) will work better on bikes without smooth tread. Fan and fluid resistance provide the most realistic feel. Fluid and magnet resistance are the quietest and best for watching TV, etc while riding.
HTH
Thursday, January 13th 2011 at 6:44 AM |
Excellent information over again. I am looking forward for more updates=)